. . .when the mom sent the newest man to help you an excellent girls’ personal date school the father performed nothing to cover the patient against this decision. This new child had no male playmates. The equipment try off superior quality together with probably become chosen with care. In the event that current was handed with the guy, the father told you, “Anybody can gamble basketball.” But the guy realized no other males having exactly who he might enjoy. (Bieber 1962, p. 101)
I’ve started to the end you to definitely an useful, supportive, warmly relevant father precludes the potential for a homosexual child; the guy acts as a beneficial neutralizing protective representative should the mommy generate seductive otherwise close-binding attempts.” (Bieber 1962, p.311)
The newest people in the Bieber’s study had looked for let because they have been let down with the lives or struggling to function. They may pay the cost of data. This new come across characteristics of one’s sample acceptance experts to help you issue the fresh new conclusions towards grounds these particular conclusions cannot be used to any or all homosexuals.
Its achievement: “It would appear that the family personality for gay clients demonstrated because of the Bieber, ainsi que al
Yet not, plenty of studies have verified the newest results away from Bieber. Chang and you will Take off (1960) figured gay males was indeed apt to be as compared to controls so you’re able to “disidentify and their dads.”
Simply to evaluate the latest Bieber findings, Apperson and you can McAdoo compared 23 low-diligent homosexuals and you may twenty-two members of the usa armed forces. Their end:
The outcome of investigation highly contain the theoretical formations away from Bieber et al., in given homosexuality because primarily linked to particular experiential products. The significance of the partnership — otherwise diminished they –to the father is actually once more showcased on homosexual S[ubject]s indicating designated variation on regulation within the seeing the father a great deal more once the important, excited, and you can rejecting, and less while the relationships agent. (Apperson, 1968)
Snortum, et al., held testing to the 46 men getting examined to possess break up about army due to homosexual events and you may 89 regulation. was in fact affirmed into the toto.” (Snortum, 1969)
Thompson, ainsi que al.,(1973) queried 127 white homosexual males and you may 123 matched heterosexual control and you will discovered that the fresh homosexuals was in fact more likely to report that it spent very little time due to their dads. The latest experts determined that poor 
and you will/otherwise aggressive fathers starred popular part about etiology from homosexuality.
A survey by Stephan, mais aussi al., compared 88 activist men homosexuals with 105 men heterosexuals and found that: “Towards the zero changeable performed the new homosexuals look at their dads absolutely.” Stephan concluded:
Almost all of the homosexuals don’t appear to have confident male patterns to recognize that have just like the college students, so when an outcome they may have recognized that have girls. This process is actually most likely triggerred of the simple fact that normative masculine character conclusion was not encouraged strongly by sometimes parent. (Stephan, 1973)
Bene (1965) discovered that male homosexuals have been aggressive towards its dads and you will noticed their dads since weakened
In a 1979 blog post Irving and you will Toby Bieber stated that for the the feedback more than 1,100 men homosexuals, it failed to find one “whose father openly adored and you will known your.” (Bieber, 1979)
Most other studies said equivalent results. Sherman (1985) found that homosexual sons “detected its reference to their dads as the distant, negative, and you will conflicted.” Saghir and you will Robins held comprehensive interviews with 86 gay men and you can thirty five unmarried heterosexual control, the results from which they had written in the a text size statement Female and male Homosexuality: A thorough Research (1973).Men with a reputation psychological dilemmas or incarceration have been got rid of regarding try. Centered on its declaration:
When you look at the more than that-half of brand new homosexuals brand new parental home in their teens are designated from the intense discord and you will attacking. Brand new part of your dad at home appears to be obvious by the their lack. In a startling 84% of homosexuals, the father is understood to be indifferent and you may uninvolved yourself, particularly into gay guy, as well as in an equivalent ratio the latest homosexuals determine the youthfulness dating with the fathers as the unsatisfying. (Saghir, p.152)